You should describe and address 2 main weaknesses in the paper. Explain why it is a weakness (why does it matter?), and finally propose a way that this weakness could be rectified or improved in future studies.
The two weaknesses should be about two separate issues. They can be about the theorical framework, the methodology, or the interpretation of the results and conclusions.
In describing a methodological weakness, make sure you specify why it poses an issue for the present study. For example, do not simply say the sample is not representative, instead describe why this limits our ability to draw conclusions in the context of this particular study.
You should take care to read the entire paper as you will have points removed if you point out a weakness in a study that is already addressed in the paper. The stronger and more thoughtful and coherent your arguments are, the better your grade will be.
One page and a half
0 comments